Consignment & Thrift Store Shopping in Naples

By Reagan Rule

In the Paradise Coast, a different kind of treasure hunting awaits. 

Famous for bustling high-end shopping districts and ritzy boutiques, Naples also caters to the budget-friendly bunch with a major outlet mall and numerous consignment and thrift stores stocked with pre-loved treasures and vintage goodies.

Consignment & Thrift Stores Near Downtown Naples

Tucked behind Tamiami Trail and within walking distance of luxurious Fifth Avenue South, shops along the Trail of Treasures district are scattered along 10th Street North between Fifth Avenue North and Second Avenue South. A mix of nonprofit thrift shops, resale stores and antique shops have set up shop in this district, making for a fun day of treasure hunting just a stone’s throw away from the prestigious retailers of downtown Naples. You'll find everything from costume jewelry to fine art in the 20-something stores along the cobblestone trail.

Nonprofit Shops & Resale Stores

OPTIONS Thrift Shoppe on Second Avenue North, a nonprofit consignment shop with proceeds benefiting the Shelter for Abused Women & Children, offers luxury brands at a fraction of the usual cost. The boutique section sells designer threads from Armani and Escada, shoes from Prada and Ferragamo, and an impressive array of handbags and purses from Dooney & Bourke, Kate Spade, Tod's, Coach and Gucci. The spacious store also boasts a large, upscale furniture section with pieces that look like they came directly from a showroom floor.

Shop for a cause at any one of the six thrift shops benefitting St. Matthew’s House. Carrying clothing, furniture and home necessities, St. Matthew’s House thrift stores aid the area’s homeless with self-help recovery programs, accommodations and meals. The thrift stores, located all over Southwest Florida including Naples and Immokalee, also provide jobs for Justin’s Place Recovery Program graduates.

Designer Consignments

For brands like Anthropologie, Burberry, Gucci, Kate Spade and Tory Burch, visit Designer Divas Resale Boutique. With a hand-picked collection of designer consignments and a team of sales specialists, this Naples-based resale store verifies the authenticity of all high-ticket purchases. Should you be interested in reselling a piece from your closet, opt to consign with a 50/50 split or receive cash on the spot.

Shop a hand-picked collection of designer consignments from brands like Anthropologie, Kate Spade and Tory Burch.

At Another Man’s Treasures, get lost in a sea of eclectic items – from antique diving helmets and stunning dressers to hot pink, robotic flamingos and eccentric sofa tables. The upstairs section is a fine art gallery, with famous prints by artists including Gustav Klimt, beautifully framed and eagerly awaiting a second home.

Up for Grabs is a design lover’s dream in Naples. With fine consignment furniture, artwork and interior design services, this is a one-stop shop for high-end décor and design know-how. An array of traditional heirlooms and contemporary furnishings line the store along with original oil paintings, sculptures and glass figurines.

With two locations in the Naples and Bonita Springs areas, The Find is a high-end furniture and home décor consignment store. With transitional, traditional, West Indies-Tommy Bahama style and modern furniture, there are numerous options for any home’s style.